A Touch of Alyricism

Dedicated to the equally fascinating topics of autistic advocacy and the 'sisterly sophistries' of radical gender feminism. Other topics may occasionally crop up. Contactable at alyric@gmail.com


Polemicist since Grade 8

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

JB Handley's Latest Frivol.

JB Handley has thrown the gauntlet to Paul Offit and sued him and the publisher of Autism’s False Prophets for ‘false light invasion of privacy’, whatever that means. The piece makes for fascinating reading.[HERE] According to the authors the crux of the matter lies at point 3:

“3. To stoke the fires of this controversy, to sell more copies of his book, and to place supporters of his pro-vaccination views in a more favorable and sympathetic light, Offit fictionalized the exchange between Seidel, a supporter of Offit's views, and Plaintiff, one of Offit's sharpest critics. Offit accomplished this fabrication by creating a made-up "plea" by Seidel for Plaintiff to stop promoting a certain autism therapy. Offit then falsified a "response" to this phony "plea" by quoting, completely out of context, a message that Plaintiff had posted on a different message board in response to an entirely different topic.”

So in the middle of a work of non fiction there is this piece of fiction expressly designed to make JB look really bad. I wonder what the courts will make of it. Does he look so terrible? As is usual in any of AoA's productions there is the occasional gaffe, like this one:

“If you don't like what we have to say, stop listening.We will bring the full resources of myself and Generation Rescue to stop this. We will sue you for libel and we will go after your homes and assets. My lawyers live to investigate and sue people like you.This will be your only warning.”

Did they really want the courts to know how fond of litigation JB is? Wouldn’t appear to be all that helpful to this upstanding businessman wanting to look like an offended party.

It’s a very rambly piece and hard to know what they're trying to string together given that though Kathleen is a non party in a hamfisted way there is an attempt to tie in neurodiversity to harassment of Gen rescue’s angels. But acknowledging that the harassers remain unidentified and then stringing it to unknown neurodiversity proponents is a bit of a stretch, but not for this crew apparently.

Needless to say, Columbia University Press and Paul Offitt aren’t taking this at all seriously and maybe the court’s will treat this as a piece of frivol.


Blogger Kathleen Seidel said...

Actually, the authors of that piece are Bruce A. Rubin and Elisa J. Dozono of the Portland (OR) law firm Miller Nash LLP, with Thomas A. Clare and Eunnice H. Eun of the Washington D.C. firm of Kirkland & Ellis. Oddly, the names of Handley and his attorneys have been redacted from the version of the complaint that was published on AoA.

2:54 AM  
Blogger Alyric said...

Thanks for the correction. Is it just me or am i the only one to think this extremely poorly written? It's all over the place.

5:13 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Unfortunatley, the threat to sue in Mr. Handley's fairly annoying threat are not the substance of his complaint. His complaint claims that Dr. Offit fictionalized an exchange with Ms. Seidel that never happened.

My concern, as a lawyer myself, is that Mr. Handley may actually have a case.

Concerned in Chi-town.

9:31 AM  
Blogger Matt Hogan said...

Mr Handley doesn't have a case. For an attorney you're not very smart. Name?

4:48 PM  
Blogger Alyric said...

Well I'm not a lawyer, so the whole thing is interesting for me. Quite happy to hear lawyer's opinions on this.

6:41 PM  
Blogger Alyric said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

6:41 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm not a lawyer, Alyric, but I've got a bit of legal experience - albeit in Australia instead of the US.....

But my take on this is that it's up to Handley to prove beyond doubt that the conversation between him and Kathy didn't take place. Knowing his record for telling the truth etc I think he's going to have big problems proving it - especially if Paul calls Kathy as a witness and printed proof down to times and so forth is produced. That done - Handley is as good as gone.

3:27 AM  
Blogger David N. Andrews M. Ed., C. P. S. E. said...

"But my take on this is that it's up to Handley to prove beyond doubt that the conversation between him and Kathy didn't take place."

Thing is, it's very difficult (if not impossible) to actually prove a negative. If JB Handjob has to do that, then he's most likely fucked. If, however, the court decides to make the other side prove that the exchange DID occur, then... well... we know what Kathleen's like for her detailed and meticulous logging of information - let's face it, her training is as an information scientist! :)

Basically... looks like JB Handjob's ... er ... fucked!


Beautiful! Just like a reductio ad absurbum proof! :D

6:37 AM  
Blogger BillyD said...

My name is Billy Doherty my wife and I watched the Oprah show in regards to Autism and I truly believe that Upper Cervical care can help children who suffer from autism. Upper Cervical care is a specialty within the chiropractic field that solely focuses on the first two bones in your neck, called the Atlas and Axis. If there is a misalignment in the upper neck (Atlas & Axis), it can prevent the brain from effectively communicating with the rest of the body. The part of the body that cannot effectively communicate with the brain will begin to develop symptoms and health problems. These health problems will grow worse until the misalignment (bottleneck) is corrected and effective brain to body communication is restored. Our Upper Cervical doctors have had tremendous success with helping children who suffer from autism.

I am not a doctor, just a person who has witnessed the miraculous results from an Upper Cervical Correction. There is no drugs or surgery involved, just an Upper Cervical correction to restore brain to body communication. We recently hosted a Patient appreciation dinner and one of our patients stood up and gave a testimonial about her son who suffers with autism. Her name is Robin Helms - (704) 882-6175. Her son, Dillon, went under upper cervical care two weeks before his 4th birthday. He is now 5 years old and is going great!!! I spoke with Robin last night and we both saw the story on Oprah. She also posted some information on the Oprah message board but because of the overwhelming response and postings, I thought this may be a way to ensure you and Holly get this message.

I do not want this to sound like a sales pitch because it is not. I truly believe that Upper Cervical care can help children with autism. Please contact my friend and upper cervical doctor, Ray Drury at 704-361-1680. You can also visit our website at uppercervicalcare.com to learn more about Upper Cervical care.

Thank you for taking the time to read my email and please let us help!!!!!

Billy Doherty

Robin Helms (her son is Dillon)
(704) 882-6175

11:42 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Offit's book left no doubt in my mind that he was quoting Seidel's report, not a public statement by Handley. He can accuse Seidel of fabricating the words attributed to him, but Offit can't be blamed for recording her report.

12:21 AM  
Blogger Minority said...

Well, Handley turned out to be right. Pretty funny.

8:38 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Here is the Viagra information that everyone is looking for
Generic Viagra

7:20 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

مشاركات فيديو العاب صور برامج مواقع اخبار ترجمة
العاب سيارات العاب عربيه العاب تلبيس العاب تلوين العاب للكبار العاب قص شعر العاب شك ويف العاب شيك ويف العاب shockwave العاب طيران العاب طيارات العاب صور العاب تعليميه العاب جديده العاب 2010 العاب 2009 العاب طاوله العاب العاب مشاركات
فيديو بر فيديو شعر فيديو قصيد فيديو قنص فيديو كرتون فيديو رسوم متحركه فيديو بباي فيديو اسلامي فيديو اناشيد فيديو محاضرات video islamic افلام وثائقي وثائقية فيديو مرأة فيديو طبخ فيديو مكياج فيديو ميك اب فيديو مضحك فيديو تعليمي فيديو دروس

3:46 AM  
Anonymous العاب said...

God Bless J.B. thank you for taking this on, and the whole Generation Rescue organization. It will help all of us, You have my full support.

2:06 AM  
Anonymous viagra online said...

It was an interesting case, at the end who won the case?

10:12 AM  
Anonymous العاب فلاش للتحميل said...

you should write it in acrealy way

7:17 PM  
Anonymous buy cialis said...

this case is really interesting, even though it can be described as a weird one too. Anyway, I hope not to live a situation like this one in any period of my life, because I wouldn't know what to do.

8:34 AM  
Anonymous Viagra said...

this is wonderful posting information....really great posting..thanks for sharing this information.......

10:07 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

That is some alarming and advantageous advice appropriate there. I cannot delay until the little humans go to baddy-bye so that I can plan and apply some of this being out. Thanks!
Advertising agencies in Karachi | Advertising agencies in Pakistan

3:03 AM  
Anonymous Accreditation GED Online said...

Really important written content. the information that you shown is hard to faith and many superbly i liked the way you afford things here

11:44 PM  
Anonymous High School Diploma Program said...

Really well created post i have got here,

11:45 PM  
Anonymous Emily Taylor said...

Are you getting an Error message as "error initializing QBPOS application log" ? If yes, then your Point of sale program must be damaged or your company file consists of some incorrect entries. Therefore, our experts have shared techniques to resolve the QuickBooks Point of sale initializing problem. For more queries and doubt, you can contact us at 800-579-9430.

4:42 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home